Lately it seems that I've been running into a lot of folks who have the question, "Why?" in their minds--and hearts. You know how it goes, "Why does suffering exist if God is good and in charge?" "Why did my Mom have to die?" "Why did I get fired when I was honest and hard-working?" The list is long. Back in the 1970's Rabbi Kushner "answered" the questions in His book WHEN Bad Things Happen to Good People. Actually, he didn't answer the questions. Otherwise His book would have been titled, WHY Bad Things Happen to Good People. He came to the conclusion that God is GOOD, but He's not all-powerful, therefore, He can't help us in our suffering. Kushner reasoned that if God could help us but doesn't, then He isn't good.
But what if there's more to it than that? What if God IS good, can help us, but DOESN'T sometimes. Why would God do that? The Apostle Paul helps us out through his "thorn in the flesh" situation in 2 Corinthians 12:8-10: "Three different times I begged the Lord to take it away. Each time he said, 'MY GRACE IS ALL YOU NEED. MY POWER WORKS BEST IN WEAKNESS.' So now I am glad to boast about my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ can work through me. That's why I take pleasure in my weaknesses, and in the insults, hardships, persecutions, and troubles that I suffer for Christ. For when I am weak, then I am strong." True, Paul didn't die from his "thorn in the flesh," but then again, he didn't get better either. Eventually, Paul was executed for his faith in Jesus. Surely a loving and good God wouldn't let folks die for their trust in Him?
We forget two important realities: 1) The "thief" (Satan) comes to kill, steal and destroy (see John 10:10)--there IS evil and it is at work 24/7 in our world; and 2) God gives us the opportunity to choose our actions, and many times those actions have negative consequences. Those two realities account for much suffering and death in our world. In the cases when they don't appear to: diseases such as cancer, "accidents", "acts of God" and the like, consider this: If sin had never entered the world neither would disease have entered it. Accidents are the result of poor decisions on someone's parts, and we can scarcely blame God for our poor decisions. "Acts of God" may or may not be truly acts of God. In any case God's use of natural disasters is an act of judgment on sin according to the Bible. Once again if sin had not entered the world, such acts would not occur. So, we may trace all suffering to sin--not that of the one suffering necessarily--although sometimes it is. God created the world GOOD, and put human beings in it to love Him and one another and to care for His good creation. That we did not follow God's plan is not His fault, but ours. Suffering then is the consequence of sin, and when "innocent" people suffer we may ask, "Why?" We may pray for relief as Paul did. Our faith may be strong, and yet the answer God gives may be, "My grace is sufficient for you." If Paul's healing would have provided God the most glory in the situation, then he would have been healed. The same is true in our lives. Sometimes God grants physical healing, at ALL times He grants grace that is sufficient for us. That doesn't always ease the pain when we're in it. Otherwise, Paul would have stopped asking after the FIRST request, right?
It is never easy to suffer or to watch those we love suffer and be taken from us. It isn't supposed to be--because God's ultimate will is that we be together forever! That's why He sent Jesus to DIE on the cross and pay the penalty of death for our sins, so that while the "thief" may have momentary victory here and now, God has the ultimate victory now and forever!